The In-Memory Platform of Choice for Businesses Worldwide


About Intel and Hazelcast

Intel Logo Intel and Hazelcast jointly optimize in-memory computing solutions; Intel hardware uniquely accelerates Hazelcast software, making Intel and Hazelcast truly better together. Hazelcast’s strategic co-engineering and co-innovation collaboration with Intel is designed to accelerate the performance of real-time applications, artificial intelligence (AI), and the Internet of things (IoT) solutions for enterprises.

At the center of this initiative is Project Veyron, which is focused on accelerating Hazelcast technologies on Intel platforms, including the 2nd Gen Intel® Xeon® Scalable processor and Intel® Optane™ persistent memory (PMem). The combination of Intel scalable processors with memory persistence and Hazelcast in-memory solutions offers unprecedented speed, reliability, and scalability at significantly better price /performance ratios.

Intel Optane PMem Performance

Hazelcast ran internal benchmarks to determine the performance characteristics of Optane PMem compared against DRAM. The Hazelcast benchmarks executed in various setups used a three-node cluster and a single-node as well. The members were running on dual-socket servers equipped with Intel Scalable Xeon CPUs with 1.5TB each of PMem. Twelve of the 24 total DIMM slots (6 channels per socket and 2 slots per channel) were filled with 128GB PMem DIMMs for a total 1.5TB of PMem. The other slots contained DRAM DIMMs, as the proper configuration of PMem requires a DRAM DIMM placed adjacent to a PMem DIMM, though the DRAM DIMM can have a much smaller storage capacity. The system was measured for throughput and latency using an equal combination of reads and writes using a load testing tool. The reads and writes were against a key-value store (“maps”) in which the values were data objects that ranged in size per each test run.

With the use of PMem App Direct Mode, Hazelcast was optimized to take advantage of the fast data access capabilities of PMem. Unlike other uses of PMem, App Direct Mode has a dedicated application programming interface (API) that Hazelcast incorporated in its software to achieve the fastest speeds on PMem.

The benchmarks showcase that Intel Optane is capable of achieving DRAM-like speeds in the distributed environment. As shown in the table below, the throughput performance of Optane PMem were very similar to that of DRAM. Even with data object sizes of 10KB, the throughput was similar, with the throughput for DRAM averaged 360,000 operations per second and Intel Optane exceeded 340,000 operations per second on a single node.

Data Object Size DRAM Hazelcast 4.1
128B 1.7M operation per second (ops) 1.8M ops
1KB 1.5M ops 1.5M ops
4KB 800K ops 800K ops
10KB 360K ops 340K ops
100KB 35K ops 34K ops


Intel Optane PMem Cost of Ownership

The total cost of ownership (TCO) advantage of using Intel Optane PMem instead of DRAM for storing in-memory data is significant. High-performance systems rely on in-memory data access as a much faster alternative to reads/writes on slower media, but performance gains are capped by the amount of memory available. More available memory leads to more data that is accessible at higher speeds. Plus, more memory per server in a clustered environment means fewer servers and thus less network traffic, further reducing latency.

Intel Optane DIMMs are approximately half the cost of DRAM, making Optane an attractive alternative to RAM, particularly in servers configured for 1 TB of volatile memory or more. Along with that cost advantage, benchmark testing has shown that access times for data in Intel Optane are comparable to DRAM, enabling equal performance with much lower cost.

Consider the prices for various DIMMs (rough market prices as of early 2021):

DIMM Cost per DIMM
16 GB DRAM $565
64 GB DRAM $2265
128 GB Optane $1799

The table below shows the total cost for 1536 GB DRAM in a dual-CPU server configured for the highest performance by allocating total RAM across all channels in each CPU socket/slot.

  CPU 1   CPU 2    
Channel Slot 1 (DRAM) Slot 2 (DRAM) Slot 1 (DRAM) Slot 2 (DRAM) Totals
1 64 GB 64 GB 64 GB 64 GB  
2 64 GB 64 GB 64 GB 64 GB  
3 64 GB 64 GB 64 GB 64 GB  
4 64 GB 64 GB 64 GB 64 GB  
5 64 GB 64 GB 64 GB 64 GB  
6 64 GB 64 GB 64 GB 64 GB  
Total Capacity 384 GB 384 GB 384 GB 384 GB 1536 GB
Total Cost $13,590 $13,590 $13,590 $13,590 $54,360

Now consider the optimal configuration for Intel Optane at a comparable memory level as the configuration above. Some DRAM is required in the server, so we choose the smallest DRAM DIMMs (16 GB), coupled with Optane PMEM DIMMs (128 GB).

  CPU 1   CPU 2    
Channel Slot 1 (DRAM) Slot 2 (PMEM) Slot 1 (DRAM) Slot 2 (PMEM) Totals
1 16 GB 128 GB 16 GB 128 GB  
2 16 GB 128 GB 16 GB 128 GB  
3 16 GB 128 GB 16 GB 128 GB  
4 16 GB 128 GB 16 GB 128 GB  
5 16 GB 128 GB 16 GB 128 GB  
6 16 GB 128 GB 16 GB 128 GB  
Total Capacity 96 GB 768 GB 96 GB 768 GB 1728 GB
Total Cost $3390 $10,794 $3390 $10,794 $28,368

For a 1536 GB DRAM-only server, the memory cost is $54,360, compared to an Optane-enabled server with 1728 GB total memory, for $28,368. This represents 48% lower cost for the Optane configuration.

Intel/Hazelcast announcement regarding Project Veyron

“Intel is laser-focused on revolutionizing how organizations, regardless of size, maximize the impact of data,”
Lisa Davis
Vice President and General Manager of Digital Transformation & Scale Solutions, Intel
“The Hazelcast platform enables high-performance applications at extreme scale running best on Intel products. The Intel and Hazelcast collaboration will deliver platform innovations so that customers of Intel and Hazelcast will be positioned for greater success in the data-centric era.”
Lisa Davis
Vice President and General Manager of Digital Transformation & Scale Solutions, Intel